A Good Deal Isn’t a Good Deal If You Didn’t Plan to Buy It
There’s something exciting about finding a really good deal.
Maybe it’s a Christmas gift you’ve had your eye on, a new appliance you’ve been thinking about replacing or something you’ve wanted for yourself.
When the price drops, it feels like an opportunity.
And sometimes it is.
But with Black Friday, Cyber Monday and the holiday shopping season approaching, I think it’s worth asking ourselves a simple question:
Are we actually saving money, or are we spending money because something is on sale?
It’s an easy distinction to overlook, especially when we’re surrounded by advertisements promising the lowest prices of the year.
I certainly don’t think there’s anything wrong with enjoying a sale. I just believe the best purchases are the ones we feel good about long after the excitement of getting a deal has worn off.
A Discount Doesn’t Always Mean You’re Saving Money
Imagine you’ve been planning to buy a $200 Christmas gift, and you find it on sale for $150.
That’s a genuine opportunity to save $50 on something you already intended to purchase.
Now imagine you’re browsing online and see a $200 item marked down to $120. You hadn’t been looking for it, and you don’t really need it, but the 40% discount makes it difficult to pass up.
It might feel like you’ve saved $80. But you’ve also spent $120 that wasn’t part of your plan.
That’s why one of my favourite questions to ask before making a purchase is:
Would I still want this if it wasn’t on sale?
If the answer is no, it might be worth leaving it behind.
Make Your Shopping List Before the Sales Start
In my last blog, I talked about the importance of planning your holiday spending before December arrives.
That same planning can be especially helpful during Black Friday.
Before the sales begin, take a few minutes to write down what you’re actually shopping for.
Think about the people on your gift list, any household purchases you’ve been planning and what you can comfortably afford.
Having that list gives you something to refer back to when an advertisement catches your attention.
You can still enjoy finding a bargain. You’re simply looking for savings on things that already have a place in your budget.
And if you come across something unexpected, you have an opportunity to decide whether it truly fits.
Don’t Let the Countdown Make the Decision for You
We’ve all seen the messages.
“Only three left!”
“Sale ends tonight!”
“Your cart is waiting!”
Retailers understand that a sense of urgency can encourage people to make decisions quickly.
Sometimes those offers are legitimate. But that doesn’t mean you need to make an immediate purchase.
For something that wasn’t on your shopping list, consider giving yourself 24 hours before deciding.
You might discover that you still want it the next day. Or you might realize the excitement was more about the discount than the item itself.
Either way, you’ve given yourself a little space to make a thoughtful decision.
Compare the Price, Not Just the Discount
A big percentage doesn’t always mean you’re getting the best price.
Before making a larger purchase, it’s worth comparing prices at a few retailers and checking what the item normally sells for.
Sometimes a product advertised at 50% off isn’t significantly less expensive than it was a few weeks earlier.
You may also want to consider shipping charges, return policies and whether the item is genuinely the quality you’re looking for.
The goal isn’t to spend hours researching every purchase. It’s simply to make sure the deal is as good as it first appears.
Be Careful When Small Payments Make Big Purchases Feel Affordable
Another thing we’re seeing more often is the option to divide purchases into smaller payments through Buy Now, Pay Later services.
Instead of paying $300 today, you might be offered four payments of $75.
That can make a purchase feel easier to manage. But the total cost hasn’t changed.
And when several purchases are divided into payments, those commitments can begin to overlap.
Depending on the arrangement, missed payments may also result in fees or other financial consequences.
Before choosing a payment plan, I encourage people to look at the full purchase price and ask whether it fits comfortably within their budget.
A smaller payment doesn’t necessarily make something more affordable.
Remember What You’re Really Shopping For
The holidays can bring a lot of pressure to make everything special.
We want to find the perfect gifts, host a wonderful dinner and create memories for the people we love.
Those are lovely intentions.
But I think it’s important to remember that the amount we spend isn’t what makes those moments meaningful.
Sometimes the most appreciated gift is something thoughtful rather than expensive.
Sometimes the best part of Christmas is simply having everyone together.
And sometimes choosing not to buy something gives us more freedom to spend on what really matters to us.
That’s something worth keeping in mind when the advertisements start telling us what we should want.
The Best Deal Is One That Fits Your Life
I don’t want anyone to feel that they shouldn’t enjoy Black Friday or take advantage of a good sale.
If you’ve planned for a purchase, found a better price and can comfortably afford it, that’s wonderful.
But if you’re buying something simply because the discount feels too good to miss, it may be worth reconsidering.
Before checking out, try asking yourself three questions:
- Was I already planning to buy this?
- Does it fit within the amount I’ve decided to spend?
- Will I still feel good about this purchase when the credit card statement arrives?
Those few moments of reflection can make a real difference.
Financial planning isn’t about saying no to everything you enjoy. It’s about making choices that support the life you want, both today and in the future.
And sometimes, the smartest purchase is the one you decide not to make.
If you’d like help creating a spending and savings plan that gives you room to enjoy life while staying focused on your financial goals, I’d be happy to have that conversation.
At YourStyle Financial, it always comes back to one question: What’s Important to You?
— Samantha
